What changed
A new buyer’s guide released by theCUBE Research highlights the complexities of AI sovereignty, focusing on control over data and models. The guide outlines five pillars—territorial, operational, technological, legal, and financial—to assess how well providers manage data sovereignty. Amit Eyal Govrin, lead analyst for sovereign AI at theCUBE Research, emphasized that sovereignty is not a single checkbox but a stack of control layers that buyers must examine.
What this means in practice
The guide evaluates seven hyperscalers across 40 offerings, grading them based on 17 yes-or-no tests. Legal aspects are assessed separately due to the influence of local laws. Govrin noted that while Google’s air-gapped offerings scored relatively well, no hyperscaler had a clear answer to the U.S. CLOUD Act. This means that if a U.S. court issues a production order, data stored with a hyperscaler could be compelled to be turned over, effectively making it U.S. data.
Limitations and availability
The guide’s findings highlight the lack of clarity around the U.S. CLOUD Act’s impact on data sovereignty. Govrin pointed out that even if data is hosted in a sovereign region, such as AWS Frankfurt for German customers, there is no guarantee that data will remain under the control of the data owner. The guide also underscores the importance of legal frameworks in shaping AI infrastructure choices, with the U.S. CLOUD Act and incoming European regulations playing a significant role. The supplied announcement does not specify the exact scoring methodology or the full list of hyperscalers evaluated.
